Ulterior motives could be behind superbug claim: India
Upset over claims that a drug resistant superbug was traced to the country, India Friday said there was need to find out whether some 'ulterior motives' were behind the claim and added that a major pharma company had funded the study.
'It (superbug) is universal and is found in the intestine of humans and animals. It is wrong to say that it is found only in India and Pakistan. They say it was found in patients who visit India and Pakistan. The study nowhere mentions if the bacteria were found even before those persons visited India,' Health Minister Ghulam Nabi Azad said.
Pointing a finger at pharmaceutical companies, Azad said: 'The study was funded by a pharma company which is one of the biggest antibiotics maker in the world.'
According to a report in a British scientific journal, a new superbug had been detected in at least 37 cases in that country, mainly among patients who had travelled to India and Pakistan for cosmetic surgery, cancer treatment and transplants.
Scientists have warned that the superbug -- an enzyme they have called New Delhi metallo-beta-lactamase-1 or NDM-1 -- could spread worldwide because it is resistant to almost all antibiotics and nothing has been developed to combat it.
Minister of State for Health Dinesh Trivedi said India cannot take the reports lying down and should get to the bottom of it.
'We are all concerned about it. The superbug is a global phenomenon. It is not area or country specific. I can tell you this with all the responsibility under my command,' he said.
With Kumarswamy Kartikan, one of the co-authors of the report, disassociating from the report, Trivedi said: 'Obviously, we have to find out if there are some kind of ulterior motives or not of some pharmaceutical industries as well. I personally feel that sometimes, some things are commercially motivated.'
In an attempt to counter any adverse effects of the study, the tourism ministry sought to reassure that India is a 'safe and preferred medical tourism destination'.
An official spokesman of the tourism ministry stated: 'India is fast emerging as a global medical health care destination because of its world class medical facilities which are manned by highly qualified doctors and paramedics. Almost all Indian hospitals servicing medical tourists are accredited either by Joint Commission International (JCI) or National Board for Accreditation of Hospitals and Health Care and follow international safety standards.'
The members of the Hospital Infection Society India (HISI) and Indian Association of Medical Microbiologists (Delhi Chapter) said that the study needs to be critically analysed in the light of the fact that it has been funded and sponsored by a pharma company.
According to HISI all major hospitals in India have well defined Hospital Infection Control programmes. Moreover, in many hospitals of India the infection indices are now monitored using National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) data as a benchmark tool as per international standards.
'India is emerging as a hub for providing quality medical care at an affordable cost. It appears the study is economically motivated to prevent people from indulging in medical tourism in this region, besides promoting the antibiotic,' said T.S. Jain, president, HISI.
Comments
More Bombay News
RSS-
Three men acquitted of rape charges after victim recants
A Delhi court acquitted three men facing charges of abducting and gang-raping a woman after the victim denied that the accused raped her. Additional Sessions Judge T.R. Naval acquitted Nazeemuddin, Deepak Aggarwal and Idris Malik of the rape charges, saying that the victim failed to support the prosecution case. It added that she had specifically denied that these accused took turns to rape ...
-
Illegal structures on Yamuna Hindon banks to be demolished
The National Green Tribunal (NGT) Monday ordered the demolition of all unauthorised structures on the flood plains and river beds of Yamuna and Hindon rivers in Haryana, Delhi and Uttar Pradesh, officials said. "All illegal and unauthorized constructions either temporary or permanent and raised without the permission of any competent authority are to be demolished in Haryana, UP (Uttar Pradesh) ...
-
No questions for visiting leaders
Media interactions with visiting leaders are becoming little more than photo-ops with journalists being given no opportunity to ask questions of the dignitaries. This was also the case during the signing of agreements and media statements Monday at Hyderabad House after talks between Chinese Premier Li Keqiang and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Both Li and Manmohan Singh, after their ...
-
Tibetans protest near Lis hotel
Three Tibetan activists Monday defied security and managed to stage a small protest here near the Taj Palace Hotel where Chinese Premier Li Keqiang is staying, police said. Another group of 300 Tibetans held a march elsewhere. Three Tibetan students climbed a structure in a filling station near Li's hotel and shouted slogans for a free Tibet, an official said. Displaying a banner that read "Li ...
-
Infosys to appeal against tax demand
Indian IT bellwether Infosys Ltd Monday said it would appeal against the notice of the income tax department demanding Rs.577 crore as outstanding dues for fiscal 2008-09. "We are in the process of filing an appeal before the commissioner of income tax as the demand notice does not take into consideration the clarification issued Jan 17, 2013 by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT)," the ...
-
1993 Mumbai blasts convict comes on wheelchair to surrender
Two elderly and ailing convicts in the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts case were respectively brought on a stretcher and a wheelchair to surrender before a TADA Special Court here Monday to serve their sentence. While Zaibunissa Kazi, 75, suffering from multiple ailments including cancer, was brought on a wheelchair, Sharif 'Dada' Parkar, 80, was brought in an ambulance on a stretcher before ...
-
Is Preity Zinta serious about joining politics
Saddened by the current situation in the country, actress-businesswoman Preity Zinta is "thiking" about joining "politics" as she wants to be part of a movement to bring positive changes in India. Currently busy promoting her first production venture "Ishkq in Paris", Preity said: "Off late, I have been thinking that I will join politics because it's so sad what is happening to our ...
-
Girish Taurani finds comparison with Saif normal
The looks of Girish Taurani, new kid on the block, are being compared to Saif Ali Khan and he says it's normal to be compared with a senior actor. "Whenever a newcomer comes, people try to relate him with somebody. Many actors have been compared with established stars, so I think it's normal. I think it's a positive thing that they are comparing, but when you will see the film you will realise ...
-
Focus is on playing good cricket Rohit Sharma
Mumbai Indians skipper Rohit Sharma doesn't want his team to get distracted by the spot-fixing controversy in the Indian Premier League (IPL) and says the focus is on playing good cricket against two-time champions Chennai Super Kings in the first qualifier here Tuesday. "We don't want to think too much about it (spot-fixing). We are all professional cricketers and we have an important task at ...
-
Patnaik seeks early nod for Odisha bill on chit funds
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik Monday sought an early presidential nod to a bill which the state passed about a year and a half ago to protect the interest of small depositors. Patnaik wrote to Home Minister Sushilkumar Shinde seeking his intervention for expediting the presidential assent to the Odisha Protection of Interests of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Bill, 2011, an ...
-
Comedian Kapil turns producer
Actor-comedian Kapil Sharma marks his debut as a producer with TV show "Comedy Nights With Kapil". Adding to the madness, he will be seen donning multiple avatars, that of an actor, scriptwriter and producer in his production debut. Known for his strong comic timing as well as his ability to find humour in any situation, he will present a distinctive take on everyday life in a fresh way. The ...
-
Royals file police complaint suspend players contracts
The Rajasthan Royals Monday filed a police complaint against their three players arrested for alleged spot-fixing in IPL matches and, pending inquiry, suspended the trio's contracts. "Based on the information provided by the authorities, the contracts of all three players have been suspended pending enquiry. We have already filed a complaint with the Delhi Police against all three players ...
-
Lodge FIRs against two BSP ministers UP Lokayukta
The noose tightened against BSP leaders Monday with the Uttar Pradesh Lokayukta asking Chief Minister Akhlish Yadav to lodge first information reports (FIR) against two former ministers for corruption. While Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) chief and former chief minister Mayawati got off the hook in the multi-crore memorial scam being probed by the Lokayukta, two of her senior ministers -- Babu Singh ...
-
Man accused of violence against Dalit woman activists arrested
The man accused of bullying and physically abusing five Dalit woman activists in Uttar Pradesh's Lalitpur district last week, was arrested there Monday, police said. He was presented before a court which sent him to 14 days' judicial custody. Lalitpur's Superintendent of Police J.P. Singh told IANS that they were on the trail of Sahab Singh Yadav for the last five days and succeeded in nabbing ...
-
SC slams lapses in posting primary education workers
The Supreme Court Monday gave vent to its ire over state governments flouting guidelines for the appointment of 'Shiksha Sahayaks' for promoting primary education saying it amounted to "spoiling the future of the future generations". As senior counsel U.U. Lalit, appearing for the Gujarat government, rose to make his submission, the apex court vacation bench of Justice B.S. Chauhan and Justice ...
-
Now posh residents protest lack of water
Residents of the posh DLF City here Monday staged a noisy protest against the developer, saying the area was getting very little water despite the scorching heat. People from DLF City Phase III, including women and the elderly, blocked the Moulsari Venue Road for more than two hours. Joginder Singh, president of the Resident Welfare Association, said the DLF management had been told about the ...
-
India-China stress on peace boosting economic ties
India and China Monday stressed on maintaining peace and tranquility along their border and on boosting trade ties, including inviting Chinese firms to invest in India in infrastructure development and increasing banking and financial cooperation. In a joint statement issued after talks between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and visiting Chinese Premier Li Keqiang, both sides reaffirmed that ...
-
Heat scorches north India
Most parts of north India reeled under intense heat Monday with no respite in sight Tuesday, with the temperature touching a scorching 46.2 degrees Celsius at Palam airport here. It was a hot start to the week in the national capital Monday with the temperature shooting up to five notches above average at 44.5 degrees Celsius, recorded at Safdarjang airport. No respite seems to be in sight as ...
-
Chinese PM meets Sonia
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang Monday met United Progressive Alliance (UPA) chairperson Sonia Gandhi. The premier spent around 40 minutes at Gandhi's 10 Janpath residence, said a party source. Earlier, opposition leader Sushma Swaraj called on Li. After meeting Gandhi, Li called on Vice President Hamid Ansari. --Indo-Asian News ...
-
China accepts there are some problems with India but wants to resolve all issues peacefully
Chinese Premier, Li Keqiang, alluding to recent skirmishes on their Himalayan border, acknowledged on Monday, that there were some problems with good friend India but said that the two Asian giants should take a leaf out of their vast history to resolve all issues peacefully. "Since we are strategic partners and we are good friends that can speak to each other with candour, so we do not deny ...
-
GPS mandatory for Gurgaon company vehicles
Vehicles used by companies in Gurgaon to ferry female employees will have to be equipped with GPS within a month. District Magistrate P.C. Meena Monday made the Global Positioning System mandatory to ensure women's security, a police spokesperson said. The order will apply to vehicles employed by the BPO sector, call centres, business establishments and corporate sector to pick up and drop ...
-
Lowy India Poll 2013 study 83 percent Indians consider China a security threat
An opinion poll conducted with samples across India has revealed that a large majority of people, 83 percent, considered China as a security threat, though 63 percent would like relations with China to strengthen. The poll, titled 'India Poll 2013: Facing the future - Indian views of the world ahead' conducted by the Lowy Institute for International Policy and Australia India Institute (AII), ...
News from around our Network
Comments
No comments yet for this story
Have your say